A couple of years ago, some friends invited me to a night at the theater that seemed a little peculiar: A musical version of the cult horror/gore film Re-Animator. I was in a strange position to see this live show, since I knew nothing about the movie, but it was odd enough that I couldn’t say no.
The live show itself seemed like straightforward hipster irony: Mash up two forms (musical + horror) into something weird and unpredictable, sure, why not. And there was certainly plenty of stage blood, fake entrails, and goofy wide-eyed mugging to the audience to make it a fun time. But I couldn’t figure out why, of all movies, this one was adapted.
I mean, I know Re-Animator is super popular with a certain kind of horror nerd, and that it’s a foundational text for a lot of gore-movies today. But somehow I’d just never seen it. So I didn’t get it.
But now I’ve finally caught up with everyone else and with the mid-80s. I watched Re-Animator for the first time last night and at last I understand. I took some notes as I watched — follow along for my impressions from the film.
0:40 The movie opens with people walking urgently down a hall in an overwrought way that reminds me of High Anxiety. Is this just a straight up goofy comedy?
1:20 Well a guy’s eyeballs just exploded so probably not a comedy.
2:50 Weirdly, the music is literally just a copy of Psycho with a dance beat.
9:14 The hero’s address is 66 Darkmore, so maybe it is a comedy after all?
15:00 Just watched a man’s scalp slowly peeled off of his skull. Probably shouldn’t have sat down to watch this movie while eating.
22:26 Okay, there’s a crazy doctor living with the hero. This is basically “Frankenstein’s Roommate.” Still not sure if that makes it a comedy, though!
27:16 They’re about to reanimate a dead cat that looks like they just cut a cat shape out of a bathmat.
33:40 A character was just posing as a dead body, then when it was safe to do so got up and put on clothes. But he was wearing a toe tag, and pulled a sock on without removing the tag. That is the most upsetting thing that has happened so far, and there’s been a LOT of blood.
40:35 I normally like male nudity in a film, but this naked muscle man just had a bone saw embedded through his body, which kind of reduces the sexiness. Still, he has a nice butt.
45:40 There is a man guarding the morgue in a weirdly tight shirt that gives him incredible breasts.
1:01:00 The mad scientist is acting like Steven Colbert acting like a mad scientist. I think it’s a comedy! I’m still not sure!
1:04:20 The dean just got a lobotomy and it made his hair very silly. I think it’s a comedy! But then again it’s been really gross and gloomy up until this point so I’m still not totally sold.
1:19:20 Well, okay. We just watched a whole bunch of zombies staggering around, which sure seems like horror to me. But we also saw a headless body walking around and bumping into things, which seems like comedy. There was a sad death — horror! — but also a rib cage flapping like barn doors at a saloon — comedy?
So the verdict on this movie’s genre is: There is no possible verdict. It has no genre. It is its own genre.
And that’s why it makes so much sense as a musical. Re-Animator already exists outside of the bounds of any “type” of film. And so slapping one more type on top of it — one more category — is perfect. The movie spends an hour and a half careening between hilarious (for example, putting a goofy fake head on a torso to avoid detection) to macabre (lots of dismemberments). So heck, if it’s going to be a genre-buster, why not pile as many genres on top of that sandwich as you can?
The Re-Animator musical doesn’t seem to be going on anymore, which is a shame. Now that I’ve seen the film, I think I’d be in a much better position to appreciate it. Oh well… maybe someday I’ll get to see the Evil Dead musical.
Previously published August 28, 2016.
Read more stories by just signing up
or Download the App to read the latest stories